Democracy and Artificial Intelligence: Theoretical Challenges of Decision-Making

Abstract

Democracy is a form of modern governance in which values such as public participation, transparency, representation and accountability are considered paramount. In the changing global scenario, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has emerged with new possibilities and challenges in the field of democratic processes and decision-making. On the one hand, AI-based data analysis, opinion polls, assessment of policy options and opportunities to enhance administrative efficiency, on the other hand, it raises a deep question mark on the basic structure of democratic values. The intervention of AI in the decision-making process presents several theoretical challenges. First, the question of transparency is important because the complexity of the algorithm makes the decision-making process opaque to citizens. Second, a clash of representation and technological dominance is observed, where machine-based inferences sometimes limit the diversity of public opinion. Third, there is the issue of accountability and ethics - If the decision taken by AI violates democratic rights, who will be responsible? Fourth, maintaining a balance between human conscience and machine logic is absolutely essential for democracy. Many developed and developing democracies globally are grappling with the opportunities and risks of using AI. The challenge is even more complex in the context of India because of its high population, diversity and social inequalities. Therefore, a balanced regulatory framework, ethical guidelines and protection of democratic values are essential for the use of AI. This study makes it clear that while artificial intelligence can speed up and improve democratic decision-making, ignoring its theoretical challenges can jeopardise the fundamental ideals of democracy. Therefore, it is the balanced co-existence between democracy and AI that will determine the direction of future governance.